No, senator, science can't do away with models
scientific-modelingcomputational-modelingepistemology
Abstraction: Defense of mathematical models as essential to scientific method
Key points:
- Senator John Cornyn claimed (April 2020, COVID context) that models are not part of the scientific method — scientists responded with bafflement
- Conceptual models are fundamental to all scientific thinking, not just mathematical simulations; every reasoned prediction relies on an internal model
- Mathematical simulations are one point on a broad spectrum of model types, all of which are indispensable to science
- "You can make a model say anything" is a bad-faith or ignorant argument — models can be wrong or uncertain, but that does not make them unscientific
- Some models can be genuinely poor, but this is an argument for better models, not no models
- Criticism of scientific conclusions by attacking modeling as a method is fundamentally misleading about how knowledge is produced
Connections: Scientific Modeling · Computational Modeling
Source: https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/04/no-senator-science-cant-do-away-with-models/